Why and how do you design a paddle blade to be asymmetrical?
Asymmetrical designs are meant to create a balanced
blade by creating equal surface areas on each half
of the blade as it enters the water. The right amount
of asymmetry will reduce fatigue by eliminating torque,
or twisting of the paddle, when the blade enters the
water. Typically the lower part of the blade hits the
water first and will torque or twist if there is not
asymmetry. The right amount of asymmetry creates a
smooth entry of the blade into the water allowing you
to use a light grip to reduce fatiguing your hands
and arms.
The amount of asymmetry needed is typically determined
by the angle the blade should enter the water. For
example, on low angle designs more of the lower half
of the blade reaches the water first, causing it to
torque… so more asymmetry is needed or more
of this half of the blade needs to be cut away to create
balance. Less asymmetry is used on higher angle designs
because both halves of the tip area enter the water
at nearly the same time. On really thin designs like
Greenland-style paddles, asymmetry is much less of
an issue because they have so little surface area.
--Andy Bridge, Werner Paddles
Click
here to read Bio
Asymmetrical blades help
balance the forces of the water acting on each side of
the centerline of the blade. This only affects the blade
if the paddler is pulling the blade through the water
when the blade is not fully submerged. Once the blade
is fully in the water, forces will be balanced whether
the blade is symmetrical or asymmetrical. Asymmetric
blade designs need to take into account the type of paddling
that it will be used for. If the paddle is for high-angle
and high cadence paddling then the angle of “balance” needs
to match the angle of the blade entering the water.
--Peter Mitchell, Mitchell Paddles
Click
here to read Bio
Any good blade should
be asymmetrical to stop the blade from torquing upon entrance
to the water. If you have a symmetrical tip, when the blade
enters the water at the start of the stroke, there will
be more blade area on the bottom side causing the blade
to want to twist in your hand. You will find yourself
gripping the shaft hard, trying to stop this, thus
wasting energy. With a well designed blade, you should
be able to pull the blade toward you with your fingertips
and push away with your palm. You shouldn’t have
to grip the shaft at all.
--Dave Bain, Nimbus Paddles
Click
here to read Bio
Asymmetry maximizes the power
of the blade as it is inserted and takes into consideration
the angle of attack. However, the perpendicular asymmetry
must be balanced by a longitudinal symmetry or the blade
will want to twist in the water. This means that there
must be an equal surface area on either side of the center
line of the blade regardless of the depth of insertion.
--Tom Derrer, Eddyline Kayaks
Click
here to read Bio
A good design creates near
equal amounts of force on each half of the blade as it
enters and exits the water. When these forces are equalized,
torque is minimized, allowing the paddle to pull smoothly
through the water, decreasing the need to hold the paddle
so tight. It is very important to have the right balance
of asymmetrical halves and dihedral design on the blade.
Too much dihedral is bad for the overall performance of
the paddle blade. A good design will have accomplished
this by a balancing of blade halves, size, shape, slope,
and dihedral.
Blade shape has a lot to do with how the paddle pulls
through the water and helps minimize the shaft torque.
The twisting motion of the shaft caused by unequal
pressure on each half of the blade can only be overcome
by adding more dihedral.
--Dale Kicker, Bending Branches
Click
here to read Bio
We use asymmetrical blades
for their stability, efficiency and ability to reduce torque.
Our designs ensure that as the blade is immersed, the centre
of pressure runs up the centre line of the paddle which
gives a balanced catch in the water.
--Alistair Wilson, Lendal Paddles
Click
here to read Bio
Because the paddle is not vertical in the water (from
a front view), a symmetrical paddle will not have balanced
pressure and will create a twisting moment on the shaft.
The cross sections can be designed at an angle to create
better pressure distribution. We go a step further
and manipulate the sections to decrease interference
with the deck of the kayak and give a balanced feel
in the water.
--Greg Barton, Epic Kayaks
Click
here to read Bio